Podcast

“It was a pretty Wild West era”: Simon Thomsen, Editor, Startup Daily at Pinstripe Media

Startup Daily Editor Simon Thomsen joined Steve to talk about his journalism background and all his years covering the Australian & New Zealand tech ecosystem.

by hao-nguyen on July 24, 2022

About the guest

Simon Thomsen

Editor at Startup Daily, Pinstripe Media

Simon Thomsen is the editor of Startup Daily, the preeminent site for startup and tech news in Australia and New Zealand. He was previously Associate Editor of Business Insider Australia, restaurant critic and editor of The Good Food Guide for the Sydney Morning Herald, and a newspaper proprietor in the Northern Rivers region of NSW for nearly fifteen years. He is also an investor in early-stage startups and hosts the Startup Daily show on ausbiz.com.au.

Episode overview

Simon Thomsen joins Give It A Nudge to turn the tables on Steve Grace, who usually does the interviewing. Simon walks through a career that spans regional newspaper ownership, online journalism in its earliest days, the launch of Business Insider Australia, and three years as editor of Startup Daily. The conversation covers what has changed in the Australian startup ecosystem over the past decade, why Canva and Atlassian are defining moments for the country, and how the next generation of founders is being shaped by values in ways that were almost unheard of in the corporate raider era of the 1980s.

From regional newspapers to startup media

Simon’s career in media started not at a national masthead but in a regional newspaper he bought in his mid-twenties from owners who were going to close it. The Northern Rivers Echo in Lismore was about twelve to fifteen months old when he acquired it with a couple of others, and he ran it for nearly fifteen years before selling to APN News and Media. In 1996 he put up one of the first newspaper websites in Australia, beating Fairfax and News Corp, not out of strategy but because he saw the internet as a distribution opportunity for readers who had moved overseas.

“I used to describe it as the conversation we have over the back fence. That’s what the Northern Rivers Echo was. It was that conversation that people have. It was all about community.”

Simon Thomsen 6:00

It was a pretty Wild West era

Simon describes the early Australian startup ecosystem as resembling the corporate raider period of the 1980s, when figures like Bond, Skase, and Holmes a Court operated with few constraints. The nascent startup world of 2012, when Startup Daily launched, had a similar energy: few guardrails, enormous enthusiasm, and some spectacular failures alongside the early wins. Now, with Atlassian at 100 billion dollars and Canva a global brand, the ecosystem has matured, but Simon argues the values shift is the most significant change: founders like Melanie Perkins and Mike Cannon-Brooks are defining their legacies during their companies’ growth, not at the end of their careers.

“It was a pretty Wild West era in terms of business and how it was conducted. Now we’ve got a generation whose values have shifted quite dramatically.”

Simon Thomsen 16:00

What makes a startup story worth covering

Simon describes his editorial filter as two poles: an idea is either so obvious you can’t believe nobody did it before, or so completely out of left field you can’t understand how someone’s brain produced it. Linktree is the obvious category: it solved a single friction point that millions of people felt every day. Most of the breakthrough companies are in the obvious category. The out-of-left-field ones are rarer but tend to produce the most memorable conversations. He is also honest that not every founder he has interviewed delivered, though those are the minority.

“The most amazing thing is being on a show where every day I’m inspired. I am blown away by people doing extraordinary things.”

Simon Thomsen 20:00

The next generation of investors

Simon points to the emergence of a second-generation investor class as one of the most significant structural changes in the Australian startup ecosystem. Founders who have exited, senior operators from scaled startups, and employees who have accumulated capital through early-stage equity are now deploying their own capital as angels. They are writing cheques of twenty to twenty-five thousand dollars rather than the millions that make the headlines, but they are backing founders at the earliest stage and bringing real operating experience to bear.

Key takeaways

Community media survives on authenticity, not sophistication. The Northern Rivers Echo was not trying to win journalism awards. It was the conversation people had over the back fence, made visible and distributable. That same principle applies to modern media: the voice has to match the community it serves.
The internet was obvious as a distribution channel before most people saw it. Simon put a newspaper online in 1996 not out of strategic foresight but because the problem was distribution: expats who had moved away from the Northern Rivers couldn’t read the paper. The internet solved that problem before anyone called it digital transformation.
Values are now part of the product for founders. The generation of founders coming through now define what their company stands for before they accumulate the wealth that would traditionally trigger philanthropy. That shift flows into hiring, culture, and how they attract and retain the talent that will build their companies.
The best startup ideas are either blindingly obvious or completely unexpected. Linktree solved a problem that millions of people had but nobody had addressed. Most successful startups are in the obvious category. The skill is in seeing the friction that everyone else has accepted as normal and deciding to remove it.
A second-generation angel investor class is emerging in Australia. Founders who have exited and startup employees who have accumulated equity are now investing as angels in the next cohort. These investors bring operational experience to companies at the stage where it matters most, and they are doing it a decade earlier in their careers than previous generations.
Editorial judgment in startup media requires getting the measure of founders. Covering early-stage companies means making bets on founders before the data is in. Simon’s process is similar to what early-stage investors do: read the person, assess the idea’s commercial viability, and accept that some will not deliver.

Mentioned in this episode

Frequently asked questions

What is Startup Daily?

Startup Daily is Australia’s leading publication covering the startup and technology ecosystem. Founded by Matt Beech in 2012, it was one of the first outlets dedicated entirely to Australian startup news. Simon Thomsen has been editor for three years and also hosts the Startup Daily show, which airs weekdays at 2pm on the business streaming service ausbiz.com.au.

What has changed most in the Australian startup ecosystem since 2012?

The scale of both companies and capital has transformed dramatically. In 2012, seed rounds were typically 250 to 500 thousand dollars. Now Series C rounds regularly exceed 100 million dollars. But the more fundamental shift, according to Simon, is cultural: founders like Melanie Perkins and Mike Cannon-Brooks are defining their legacies during the growth phase of their companies, not after retirement, which is reshaping how all founders think about the purpose of a business.

What made the early Australian startup scene a Wild West era?

Simon draws an analogy with the corporate raider period of the 1980s in Australia, when figures like Bond, Skase, and Holmes a Court operated with relatively few constraints. The nascent startup world of the early 2010s had a similar energy: enormous enthusiasm, few established norms, and some spectacular failures alongside early wins. The ecosystem has since matured with more institutional investment, stronger founder communities, and clearer governance expectations.

How does Simon Thomsen decide which startup stories to cover?

Simon describes his filter as two poles: ideas that are so obviously solving a problem that you can’t believe nobody did it sooner, and ideas that are so unexpected you can’t understand how the founder’s brain produced them. Linktree is in the first category. He also reads founders as much as ideas, using a similar approach to early-stage investors: assessing whether the person has what it takes to execute on the opportunity over a multi-year timeline.

What is the second-generation angel investor class Simon describes?

Simon points to founders who have had exits, senior operators from scaled startups, and employees who have accumulated equity as a new class of angel investors in Australia. Unlike the institutional VCs whose cheques make headlines, these investors are writing 20 to 25 thousand dollar cheques at the earliest stages, bringing operating experience from having scaled companies themselves, and doing it a decade earlier in their careers than previous generations of investors would have.

Topics discussed

startup mediaAustralian startup ecosystemjournalismStartup DailyCanvaAtlassianangel investingfounder valuesmedia entrepreneurshipdigital mediaindependent publishingtech journalism

Full transcript

Auto-generated, may contain minor errors. Click any timestamp to jump to that point in the video.

Show full transcript (31 minutes, 5 sections)

0:00 Introduction

Simon Thomsen, editor of startupdaily.net, the preeminent site for startup and tech news in Australia. Matt Beech kicked it off back in 2012, absolutely at the very start of what is now a massive wave. I am now the custodian. It couldn’t exist without the ecosystem. Government takes a great interest in what we do. They’re investing in the sector too, through the Sydney Startup Hub, Tech Central, LaunchVic in Victoria.

3:00 Simon’s career background

I always wanted to be in journalism. I ended up in copywriting, went overseas, came back, went back to university at Southern Cross in Lismore. I had a part-time job at a local independent newspaper. The owners decided they weren’t going to continue the Lismore version. I was young and foolish in my mid-20s and thought I’d have a crack. I bought it off them with a couple of others. It was about twelve to fifteen months old. I ran it for nearly fifteen years and we exited to APN News and Media.

9:00 The first newspaper website and Business Insider

In about 1996 I put up the first website for the Echo. I actually beat Fairfax, the Herald and the Age to getting a newspaper website up. I viewed it as a distribution channel. Expats who’d moved away suddenly emailed saying I love the fact that I know what’s going on in the Northern Rivers. I ended up as restaurant critic and editor of the Good Food Guide for the Herald. Then Business Insider Australia launched in 2013 under Paul Colgan and we had a great adventure for a little over five years. Then Startup Daily for the last three years.

15:00 The Wild West era and values shift

Canva is one of the greatest growth stories. Atlassian, a 100 billion dollar company, listed back in 2015. When I think about the 1980s with the corporate raiders, Bond, Skase, Holmes a Court, it was a pretty Wild West era. Now with Mike Cannon-Brooks making his play on AGL, we have a generation whose values have shifted. Mel and Cliff saying they’re going to give their money away in their lifetime. That filters into their workforce and the new generation coming in says: what does this company stand for before asking how much I get paid.

20:00 Editorial filter and the investor class

Every idea I hear is either so obvious that nobody thought to do it before, or so off the charts that I can’t understand how someone’s brain works. Linktree is the obvious one. It solved a friction point that millions felt every day. On the future: there’s a second generation of investors now. Founders who’ve had exits, senior execs from scaled startups, people with sophisticated investor status writing 20 to 25 thousand dollar cheques. We hadn’t seen that ten years ago. They bring operating experience to the earliest stage.

About the host

Steve Grace is the founder and CEO of The Nudge Group, a technology-focused recruitment and advisory business. He has built and scaled companies across Australia and the US, and hosts Give It A Nudge to spotlight founders and operators building something meaningful.

<h2>Interested in finding out<br /> more about The Nudge<br /> Group?</h2> <p>Find out more about how we work and how we can help you grow your business.</p>